Loving gay couple Cam and Greg invite over their first third, Princeton. But things take a turn after queer next-door neighbors Elsa and Reggie interrupt the evening.

While Cam visits his abuela in Vegas, Greg sees Princeton solo for the first time. Meanwhile, Elsa and Reggie start to catch on to the recent shift in Greg and Cam's relationship dynamic.

The guys question whether to keep things going with Princeton. Later, Greg, Elsa and Reggie support Cam as he performs in drag for the first time, guided by drag mother Lois Carmen Denominator.

Cam and Greg get a fresh start with a new third, Kenny. Princeton tries various methods to communicate his apologies to the guys. Elsa and Reggie debate whether a threesome is right for them...while overhearing the men's.

Cam flirts with a fellow teacher. Greg works out his issues in therapy. Princeton strategizes with his roommate to win the guys back. Elsa and Reggie invite over their first third.